Comments on: Shmula Goes Camping: Drum-Buffer-Rope and Theory of Constraints https://6sigma.com/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope/ Six Sigma Certification and Training Fri, 28 Feb 2025 06:02:59 +0000 hourly 1 By: Pete Abilla https://6sigma.com/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope/#comment-24324 Fri, 14 Aug 2015 15:28:18 +0000 https://opexlearning.com/resources/138/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope#comment-24324 In reply to Janelle Klein.

Hi Janelle – wow, thank you for the kind words. I appreciate that.

In Goldratt’s example, he discusses a boy scout troop on a hiking trail. Some of that group wish to go really fast and some moderately fast, and some slow. In his example, the entire troop goes only as fast as the boy scout in the front of the trail. That makes sense. But it can also work the other way around: The entire team can only go as fast as the slowest person on the team. That can also be the constraint.

So, since constraints are a natural phenomenon present in every dynamic system, recognizing what the constraint is in the system and then managing to it is key.

Again, thank so much for your kind words.

]]>
By: Janelle Klein https://6sigma.com/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope/#comment-24323 Fri, 14 Aug 2015 15:22:21 +0000 https://opexlearning.com/resources/138/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope#comment-24323 Hi Pete,
I know it’s been years since you wrote this article, but it’s still one of the best descriptions I’ve found of drum-buffer-rope that isn’t convoluted with tons of unnecessary detail. Since I’m currently working on a data-driven software learning technique (essentially SPC for software development), at the moment, this is very relevant to me.

I had a question. In your drum-buffer-rope picture, you have a guy in the back that you label as the “constraint”. This really confused me, since I thought the bottleneck (the drummer), would be the constraint?

I know it’s been years since you wrote this article, but would you mind explaining this part?

]]>
By: Mike Stone https://6sigma.com/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope/#comment-24322 Sun, 30 Dec 2007 22:30:57 +0000 https://opexlearning.com/resources/138/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope#comment-24322 I notice that your diagram shows the constraint and the drum being in different places. In actuality, they should be the same thing, as you say in your text.

Also, you say that you made sure that the upstream pick-rate would never be higher than the pack-rate. That is not good. There are times that the upstream pick-rate MUST be higher than the pack-rate. Those times would be that the buffer, for whatever reason, becomes depleted. Otherwise, there is no way that the buffer to the constraint can be replenished without starving throughput at the constraint, and that’s the whole point of the buffer.

The pick-rate should NORMALLY be no higher than the pack-rate for this example–as stated, the constraint acts as a drum to keep the pick-rate at the rate where maximum throughput is sustained. But the pick-rate must have excess capacity that can be called on when needed to replenish the buffer to prevent sacrificing throughput at the buffer, otherwise you would need an infinitely-long buffer to ensure that it never becomes starved.

]]>
By: jordy https://6sigma.com/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope/#comment-24321 Wed, 05 Jul 2006 16:50:13 +0000 https://opexlearning.com/resources/138/shmula-goes-camping-drum-buffer-rope#comment-24321 Goldratt’s “The Goal” really was an awesome book that totally changed the way I look at business processes. His other books are good too, but “The Goal” really is a must read. As a business novel (I know that sounds weird), it’s actually an easy read too.

]]>